In 1538, in Italy, Titian, a renowned oil painter, presented to his patron, Guidobaldo II, the Venus of Urbino, and as noted by Gardiner's Art through the Ages, pg. 267, set a new standard for the reclining nude female. In 1863, nearly three hundred years later, Manet depicted a similar painting, Olympia. Unlike Venus, Olympia set off a series of complaints from art critics, for attempting to challenge “the whole iconographic stock of traditional art” (Gardiner pg. 368)
Both artists used similar subjects, courtesans or prostitutes posing in a reclining position while servants are in the background, however the purpose of both paintings differs drastically. These differences are the subject of comparison for their similarities and differences in formal artistic elements of: subject, composition, light and dark and scale including balance. Manet's Olympia served to be a social statement on society's view on prostitution and perceived outsiders of society, while Titian's Venus was known better for introducing a new painting technique for oils and showing the beauty of a woman in a goddess like manner.
Titian painted Venus in 1583, when painting oil on canvas became more accepted in the European and Western world (pg. 267, Gardiner). The painting took place in Florence, Italy, whose subject, as requested by Titian's patron, Guidobaldo II, duke of Urbino, a beautiful and nude courtesan, only fashioned with a gold bracelet on her right hand, eating grapes with her left, reclining in her large bed chamber, all the while enticing the audience with a smile and heavy lidded stare. There are two servant girls in the background who are preparing to dress Venus as the dusk is approaching through her vista window. The overall colour scheme that is used is touches of warm yellows, gold with hints of reds.
The other piece, Olympia, similar to Venus, is of a nude, redheaded prostitute, whose hair is tied in the back, and also reclining on her bedspread. In the immediat background is one black servant who is presenting her with flowers from a client. Edourd Manet painted this piece in 1863, Paris, France in response to the “iconographic stock of traditional art” (pg. 350, Gardiner). She has a wilted flower in her hair, a black ribbon on her neck, a gold bracelet around her left bracelet and gold slippers slipping off her feet. Her gaze unlike that of Venus is not enticing but indifferent. Although the subjects in both paintings are very similar as noted above, the meaning and portrayal of both women by the artists are very different.